October 16, 2011

Review: Howard C. Stutz, “Let the Earth Bring Forth: Evolution and Scripture”


Title: Let the Earth Bring Forth: Evolution and Scripture
Author: Howard C. Stutz
Publisher: Greg Kofford Books
Genre: Evolution/Religion
Year: 2011
Pages: xvi, 87
Binding: Softcover
ISBN13: 978-1-58958-126-5
Price: $15.95 ($9.95, Kindle)
“One of the greatest tragedies in recent times has been the extensive promulgation of creeds that have created chasms between science and religion. At no time in the history of humankind has science provided a more comprehensible panorama of the universe in which we live. Nor has there ever been a time when God has more clearly revealed Himself and His purposes to His children. Why then should there be so much apparent conflict between science and religion?” (xix).
Let the Earth Bring Forth is the culminating testimony of a man who spent his life successfully exploring the realms of faith and science. In addition to earning a Ph.D in genetics at UC Berkeley and teaching at Brigham Young University, Howard C. Stutz (b. 1918) served in various church callings from bishop, to high councilor, to stake patriarch. In university and church settings he interacted with students who were unsure of how to make sense of evolution from a faithful perspective. Shortly before passing away in 2010, Stutz completed his manuscript to “point out the harmony which exists between the theory of speciation by organic evolution and revealed truths contained in hold scriptures” (xv).
Stutz repeatedly emphasizes a few guiding principles throughout the book:
1. Science and religion are not incompatible by nature. Instead, Stutz believes they share a “common quest for truth” and thus often “converge” (64). At times they differ in the types of questions they ask and the methods available to explore the questions, but “there can be no permanent impasse between human discoveries and those provided by the Lord through revelation; they are all His” (xix). Thus, all truth will eventually harmonize (65, 78).
2. As Francis Bacon explained, Stutz believes “the book of God’s word” and “the book of God’s works” must both be consulted in a search for truth (vii). The “book of God’s works” includes things like the fossil record, geographical and ecological distribution patterns of species, embryology, anatomical structure, biochemical patterns, and genetics. Each of these receive focus as Stutz attempts to explain complex scientific theories to a lay audience. While he makes use of scripture to demonstrate scientific principles, he asserts that the Bible is not a science text (67, 77).
3. Organic evolution occurs, and it is the means God prepared for the carrying out of his purposes. “God’s dictum, ‘Let the earth bring forth,’ [Genesis 1:11; Abraham 4:11] is a profound declaration about speciation by evolution,” Stutz writes. “The Earth has brought forth and is still bringing forth species after species after species. The concepts of organic evolution, as I understand them, appear to harmonize with the scriptures. Points of disharmony seem few, and these few disparities appear to be the result of either ignorance or misinterpretation. In either case, they will most likely be resolved as new light and knowledge become available” (65). Stutz is careful to distinguish his conclusions from that of many so-called “Young Earth Creationists” whose theories tend to lay further outside the bounds of mainstream scientific acceptability (xxi, 17, 23, 28, 36, 42, 49, 56, etc.).
Stutz rhetorically makes scientific principles more palatable by using correlative scriptural language. “Phenotypic plasticity” and “genetic flexibility” are described, then related to the LDS concept of “free agency” (7). Such biological processes interacting with different environments provide “beauty and variety to the face of the earth” (62). All of this is in harmony with “the great plan of God” (8, 58). Ultimately, “faith in the truthfulness of scientific discoveries…has come from extensive study, from the testimonies of others, and from personal experiences”on the part of scientists (64). Stutz is also careful to include evidence for organic evolution which residents of the Wasatch Front, presumably a large part of his target audience as well as the area in which most of his research was focused, can observe in person. Cultivated rye at a small BYU nursery, bitterbrush on Utah’s mountain slopes, Juab County saltbush, and dinosaur fossils in Vernal all receive attention as evidence for Stutz’s conclusions (10, 15, 21, 28).
Because Stutz argues that human bodies, like those of various plants and animals, emerged through biological processes over a long period of time, he needs to account for a literal Adam and Eve common to LDS belief. Although he isn’t quite specific on this point, he seems to posit a long evolutionary background preceding a time when God introduced human spirits into bodies which were at last prepared (73). He believes evidence is overwhelming that the creation of human bodies is “not unique”:
Our body is made of the same materials found in other living organisms; we use the same source of energy for growth and metabolism. Our genetic code consists of the same four nitrogenous bases that code the DNA of all living organisms. Biologically, our bodies are not unique (71).
He tackles other common LDS speculations on the origins of humans throughout the text, countering the idea that the earth was formed from multiple other earths, thus leaving a deceptive fossil record (x, 28, 79). He disagrees with the idea that the “days” in the creation accounts were periods of “one thousand years” because the text itself does not require such a reading and the evidence suggests much longer periods of time (65). He posits a general correlation between the scripture accounts and the findings of evolutionary theory: waters and dry land needed to be separated before humans would appear, seasons and atmosphere, plants and animals, creation from the “dust of the earth” all find expression in scientific discoveries (67).
Although the essay was written for a general audience, Stutz covers many complex scientific principles, a few of which left me scratching my head. He also avoids a few nagging questions I wish he would have tackled more directly. For example, he states that “Truths revealed to us through the prophets can in no wise be incompatible with truths revealed to us in our laboratories” (78). He doesn’t mention that some LDS leaders, including one who eventually became president of the LDS church, have condemned organic evolution as a false teaching, or even a “deadly heresy.” The book’s forward, written by BYU professor Duane E. Jeffery, acknowledges that, “Without question, Mormon writers have produced many anti-evolution, indeed anti-science, books” (xi). But he points to other LDS authors who have disagreed with those views. And Stutz, who “brought the first formal training in evolution to students at BYU” as written “the first book by an LDS evolutionary biologist in the strict sense of the term” (xi-xii). Stutz’s faithful fulfilling of various church callings and his multiple-decade professorship teaching such things at BYU witness that faithful members of the Church can find compatibility between the gospel and organic evolution.
Without question, Stutz’s approach leaves more questions to be asked, more puzzles to be solved. Without question, Stutz relates his perspective with wonder, humility, gratitude, and sophistication. Let the Earth Bring Forth is an excellent little introduction to questions about the compatibility of organic evolution with LDS scripture. It also includes a useful index of the scriptural citations Stutz employs. Please recommend it to all your friends who are among the 78% or so of Mormons who don’t accept evolution as “the best explanation for the origins of human life on earth.”*
_________________________________________________
*I recognize the question from this 2008 Pew survey is somewhat loaded. Even Mormons who accept the theory of evolution may be uncomfortable not acknowledging God in the process, as the question’s phrasing seems to do. Another fascinating approach to the question of LDS teachings and organic evolution is BYU professor Steven Peck’s article, “Crawling Out of the Primordial Soup: A Step toward the Emergence of an LDS Theology Compatible with Organic Evolution,” Dialogue: a Journal of Mormon Thought, 43, no. 1 (Spring 2010), pp. 1-36, .pdf available here. Also check out this guest column Peck wrote for the Flunking Sainthood blog. Also see the great (in content) and spacious (in length) discussions on evolution at the newcoolthang blog, before they got taken over by sports fanatics.

23 comments:

ricke said...

Thanks for the review, Blair. I recently purchased this book and look forward to reading it. I have never met Stutz, but I did meet and talk with Duane Jeffrey during my college career. I admire those LDS people who endured the heat of the day to make it more acceptable to take our head out of the biological sand.

BHodges said...

Thanks, ricke. I'm grateful for them, too.

amine lahragui said...

I appreciate you and hopping for some more informative posts. happy new year 2016 new year 2016 happy new year 2016 images feliz año nuevo 2016 feliz año 2016 imagenes de año nuevo 2016 happy new year images 2016 new year 2016 images new year images 2016

Anonymous said...

Thank You. You can share new year wishes & messages with your friends.
happy new year wishes
happy new year 2016 wishes
new year wishes 2016
happy new year message

Anonymous said...

Wow nice collection of
Happy New Year 2016 Images
New Year 2016 Images
Happy New Year 2016

dilwale said...

I cannot thank you enough for the article post.Really looking forward to read more. Want more.
Dilwale full movie download

Dilwale movie download

ajay said...

I really liked your post.Really looking forward to read more.
Happy new year 2016 photos, pictures
New year greeting card images

Happy Newyear said...

Thanks a lot for the article post.Really thank you! Great.
New year wishes 2016
New year wishes

hatestory3 said...

I really like and appreciate your blog.Thanks Again. Really Cool.
New year wishes 2016

Happy new year wishes 2016

anshul said...

I appreciate you sharing this blog.Really looking forward to read more. Will read on…
Happy new year quotes

New year quotes 2016

ride said...

I loved your article post.Really thank you! Will read on…
ride along 2 kickass download
ride along 2 kickass torrent

youtube to mp3 said...

This is a great article, that I really enjoyed reading. Thanks for sharing.

usps tracking
weather
facebook video downloader

imran said...

Major thankies for the article.Really looking forward to read more. Keep writing.
Best Valentines Day Quotes

The OS Wars said...

Your Site Is Very Good and The Post is Well On Topic, Thanks for Sharing it with us.

New Sad Songs 2016
miley cyrus bonds with liam hemsworth
Latest Entertainment News 2016
Tennessee Titans don't renew GM Ruston Webster
apple iphone 7 deals
Islamabad United Pakistan Super League Matches Live 2016
best poetry in urdu 2016
New Songs 2016 Indian Music Videos
public domain music 2016

FNAF World said...

Thanks for the best blog.it was very useful for me.keep sharing such ideas in the future as well. Thanks for giving me the useful information. I think I need it!
Plants vs Zombies , Solitaire,Tom And Jerry Games, Brain Games, Happy Wheels , FNAF World , FNAF , Five Nights At Freddy's

OnlineMoney Booster said...

T20 World cup 2016 Live Streaming
icc t20 wc live score
World T20 2016 Match Schedule
India vs Pakistan World T20 live score
India vs Australia t20 World Cup 2016 live score
Ipl T20 2016 Schedule
Budget Hotels in Delhi
Iindia vs South Africa T20 world Cup 2016 live

holi said...

A big thank you for your article.Really thank you! Want more.
Happy Holi Pictures For GF and BF

sonam said...

Im grateful for the article.Thanks Again. Will read on…
Holi Wishes For Greeting Cards

holi said...

Very neat article post.Thanks Again. Keep writing.
Holi Pictures For Facebook

tetris games said...

I just want to say : why you do not click to play
super mario | brain games | puzzle games | tetris | happy wheels | agario | abcya | happy wheels the game free | fnaf

Anonymous said...

BlueDart Tracking
Happy Diwali SMS
French Open Live French
<a href="http://halloweendecorations2016.com/”> Halloween Props</a>

fnaf games said...

Let’s keep out sites for your child! click:
brain games | puzzle games | tetris | happy wheels | agario | abcya | fnaf 4 | super mario games
To play for free!

slither io said...

The best space for your child to relax!: wingsio
slither io

Post a Comment

All views are welcome when shared respectfully. Use a name or consistent pseudonym rather than "anonymous." Deletions of inflammatory posts will be noted. Thanks for joining the conversation.